The Argument for Jeremiah Smith & Cam Coleman as the Next Great WR Prospect Duo
By Michael · Senior Analyst · Published May 2, 2026
Let's start with what happened the last time the NFL Draft had a genuine two-receiver argument at the top of the board. It was 2011. Georgia's A.J. Green — polished, complete, 166 collegiate receptions for 2,619 yards and 23 touchdowns — went fourth overall to Cincinnati. Two picks later, Alabama's Julio Jones, the more physically imposing of the two, landed in Atlanta. Both were 6-foot-4. Both were five-star recruits. Both went on to career receiving totals north of 10,000 yards and 65+ TDs. The debate over which one was better lasted the better part of a decade, and it still hasn't fully resolved.
Now meet Jeremiah Smith and Cam Coleman. Entering their final college seasons, they have already produced one of the most compelling pre-draft storylines since that 2011 class. Both players entered college with top 5 overall recruit rankings, both are 6-foot-3, and each player will have an opportunity to make their case this season to be the #1 WR off the board in the 2027 NFL draft.
Why the comparison holds up
The structural similarities between the 2011 and 2027 classes are striking. Green and Jones entered college as the No. 2 and No. 6 overall recruits in the 2008 class, per Rivals; Smith and Coleman were ranked No. 1 and No. 4 in the 2024 class. All four are big-bodied boundary receivers and all four project as true X receivers at the next level, capable of winning on the perimeter against press coverage rather than hiding in the slot.
Smith is the established star. Through two seasons in Columbus, he has been, by most measures, the best wide receiver in college football. His combination of size, separation, and contested-catch ability has drawn comparisons not just to Green but to Calvin Johnson. At 20 years old entering his junior year, he is as polished a prospect as the position has produced in the transfer portal era. He would have been the presumptive No. 1 pick in the 2026 draft, but he wasn't yet draft-eligible.
Coleman is the wilder card, and that's what makes this comparison genuinely interesting rather than merely theoretical. His raw numbers at Auburn — 1,306 yards and 13 touchdowns across two seasons — look underwhelming until you account for the context: he ran a simplified route tree behind an inconsistent quarterback rotation that would have muted anyone's production. The physical tools were never in question. At 6-3 with elite ball tracking, natural hands, and vertical ability that translates immediately to the red zone, Coleman is the player multiple draft analysts have described as someone who would be the undisputed WR1 in any class that doesn't include Jeremiah Smith.
<blockquote class="twitter-tweet"><p lang="en" dir="ltr">"I think we're in for an A.J. Green vs. Julio Jones 2.0 debate between Cam Coleman and also Jeremiah Smith."🔥<a href="https://twitter.com/Jordan_Reid?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">@Jordan_Reid</a> shares his thoughts on Texas' WR Cam Coleman and why he has him going 5th in his way-too-early 2027 mock draft 👀 <a href="https://t.co/FJqTKmyyR1">pic.twitter.com/FJqTKmyyR1</a></p>— NFL on ESPN (@ESPNNFL) <a href="https://twitter.com/ESPNNFL/status/2049938199191933166?ref_src=twsrc%5Etfw">April 30, 2026</a></blockquote> <script async src="https://platform.twitter.com/widgets.js" charset="utf-8"></script> ESPN draft analyst Jordan Reid on NFL Draft Daily, making his case for why the Smith–Coleman dynamic mirrors the A.J. Green vs. Julio Jones debate of 2011 — and why Coleman deserves more credit as a top-five prospect than he's currently getting.It's worth pausing on what Reid is actually saying here. He isn't just making a stylistic comparison, he's making a draft-position argument. Coleman, in his view, belongs in a genuine top-five conversation alongside Smith. Not in the second tier. Not as a complementary piece. As a co-headliner. That framing changes how you read Coleman's Auburn tape: not as a disappointment, but as a suppressed talent about to find the right stage.
Why Chase/Jefferson Doesn't Quite Clear the Bar
The most obvious counterpoint is Ja'Marr Chase and Justin Jefferson, who played together at LSU in 2019 and both became elite WRs in the NFL. The issue is that Jefferson wasn't regarded that way coming out. He was the 22nd pick. A brilliant player, but not a top-ten prospect on draft day. The Green/Jones standard, and the Smith/Coleman case, requires both players to be consensus blue-chip picks. Jefferson wasn't that. Chase was, but as a tandem they don't hold up to the same scrutiny.
Generationally, you'd have to go back through the 2010s to find another pair. Sammy Watkins and Mike Evans in 2014 is perhaps the closest - Watkins went fourth and Mike Evans went 7th, but as a pair they did not command the kind of pre-draft gravity that Green, Jones, Smith, or Coleman do.
The case for Smith and Coleman isn't just about talent. It's about draft context. The 2027 class shapes up as what analysts are already calling a generational quarterback year, headlined by Arch Manning. In a class like that, two receivers likely going in the top ten — possibly top five — is extraordinary. It means they're not just good receivers; they're so good that teams may be willing to bypass quarterback value to take them. That is exactly what happened in 2011: Green went fourth, Jones sixth, in a draft with Cam Newton going first overall, and Locker, Gabbert, and Ponder all drafted in the first 12 picks.
The September 12th litmus test
There is one more reason this comparison has teeth, and it's a game on the calendar. Ohio State travels to Austin on September 12th, meaning Smith and Coleman will be on the same field in prime time, with NFL scouts filling every section of Darrell K Royal Stadium. Green and Jones had a similar moment on September 27, 2008 when Alabama and Georgia faced off (Box score: https://www.espn.com/college-football/boxscore/_/gameId/282710061). Neither play disappointed, with both scoring a TD, 5+ catches, and 88+ receiving yards. Smith and Coleman will get a head-to-head showcase that could define the narrative of the entire 2027 draft class before the calendar turns to October.
Smith has actually struggled against Texas historically — seven catches, 46 yards, zero touchdowns across two meetings. Coleman, arriving fresh from the transfer portal, gets his first taste of that rivalry with everything on the line. Whether that game reshapes the WR1 conversation or merely reinforces Smith's standing, it will be the most-watched wide receiver matchup since the position mattered this much in a draft room.
The verdict: the Green/Jones comparison is not only fair, it may be underselling what's coming. Both players young and physically imposing, both carry five-star recruiting pedigrees, both project as boundary-destroying No. 1 receivers in the NFL. In a draft already building its own mythology around Arch Manning and the quarterback room behind him, Smith and Coleman are the subplot that could steal the whole show.
Bottom line
The best WR prospect duo heading into a final college season since Green and Jones in 2010 is Smith and Coleman — and it isn't particularly close. Chase and Jefferson are an elite NFL duo, but they weren't evaluated as equals on draft day. The Green/Jones parallel requires both players to be top-ten consensus picks with elite recruiting pedigrees and matched physical profiles. Smith and Coleman check every box. Whether Coleman's 2026 breakout at Texas closes the gap with Smith or Smith simply confirms his generational status, the 2027 draft is set up to revisit one of the draft's great debates.
COMMENTS
Loading comments…
